After talking to him, my mind just went into overdrive. For the remainder of the night, and each time my wife and I got up to feed the twins, I did nothing but think and think and think about these 12 properties. I finally reached a consensus that instead of narrowing my choices to only 4 properties (and then only 2 of those), I am actually going to try and get ALL TWELVE. I will still do my due diligence (and do a second and third time for good measure), so I'm not saying I'll get all twelve, but I'm not going to limit myself just because most are out of my farm area. One huge reason was that from all the supporting data I've gotten over the last 6 months suggests that property values will be increasing in central Texas - in some cases, by a LOT. Now, I'm not one to speculate, and I'm not going to do so this time, but having that extra bit of knowledge may influence my decision of whether to go or no-go with any/all of the properties.
My only barrier now is time. I'll need a LOT of time to gather info on all these properties and make a precise analytical result on whether I can do them. There are numerous unknowns at this time that I hope to get answers on from the owner, mainly about the rents: amounts and terms. I'll also have to no doubt take out a pretty big loan from my 401(k) for holding/acquisition costs - something my wife has already vehemantly said "NO" to before.
Edit: I got an email from the owner a short time ago with only some of the information I requested. He asked that I contact the property management company for some of the other info (i.e., lease dates, PM contract). Some of the other information I requested was just flat-out ignored. One thing he didn't respond to yet was my repeated request that I would have to take these properties Sub2 and if he was okay with me doing so. I'm guessing his refusal to answer the question but continued dialog with me can be substituted for "Yes", although, it would still be nice if he would say so. :-)
Based on the data I got so far, I was able to make a pretty good ballpark estimate on six of the properties. Taking the properties Sub2 and selling via owner financing would give me the following projected net profit figures:
Property #1: $ 20,413.37
Property #2: $ 38,267.80
Property #3: $ 12,399.41
Property #4: $ 11,350.98
Property #5: $ 22,130.99
Property #6: $ 42,806.97
------------ ------------
TOTAL $ 147,369.52
The other properties are harder to figure out since I am trying to formulate market conditions in areas I have no clue about.
I am a littl euneasy about Properties #3 and #4. I set a minimum profit of $15,000 for each property I purchase for now on, and those two fall below that criteria. If they make-or-break the entire deal, I'll take them, otherewise I'll probably pass on them.