Wednesday, May 20, 2009

PM Costs

After my last post, I sat down quickly and ran some numbers on how much I have saved on PM costs since I started landlording in July/2005. Using a baseline average of 80% of a month's rent to place a tenant and 10% of rent each month to manage, I came up with a total savings of $9,010. So in four years, I saved roughly $9,000 in PM costs alone.

Again, this is a very rough estimate as I didn't take into consideration things like opportunity costs (e.g., my time and money spent on marketing). However, I didn't add other things like overhead and other PM fees, either. For example, when the tenant called me last year about a problem with the water heater. I went over and the problem was fixed in less than 30 mins with no out-of-pocket expenses (excluding the gas to drive over). Had I been using a PM company, they would have sent a plumber out (at after hours, no less), and not only charged me with the repair, but also their added fee(s). Likewise in trying to get the two bad tenants I had out. It may have come down to actually doing an eviction with a PM company, and who knows how much that would have cost me.

So, all-in-all I've saved about $200/month these last 4 years doing PM myself. Can anyone say additional cash flow?

House #2: Gate Key

Access to House #2 is via an access gate at the front of the subdivision. A person wanting access either has to have a remote or know a code to open the gate. An alternative is a pedestrian gate, but requires a key to get in. In the ~10 years we lived there, my wife and I probably used the pedestrian gate two times - and that was very early on. In the subsequent years, we lost track of the key to the gate, since we no longer used it.

Well, one of the things the tenant requested before moving in was a key to the pedestrian gate. Not only did we not know where it was when we lived there, but having moved last December, neither of us had a clue where it would be. My wife called the HOA and they said they could reissue us a key for a $25 fee. We almost went that route until I was rummaging through my office desk and found a couple of keys lying around. Lo-and-behold, one of them was the key to the pedestrian gate. So I stopped by Lowes and made a copy and gave it to the tenant (I first made sure it worked, of course).

For people wanting to get into landlording or for people who are landlords but pay a PM company to manage their property, these are the "little" things that pop-up on occasion that need to be dealt with. Yes, they do take a little time out of your day, but do you really want to pay someone else 10-12% (or more) of the rent each month to do it? Secondly, even though a person may hire a PM company doesn't mean their worries all of a sudden disappear. For example, had I hired a PM company for this house, this is what would have transpired:

1. The PM company would have called me asking for the key.
2. Not having a key, the PM company would have called the HOA to send one to the tenant.
3. The PM company would have charged me $25 for the fee, and more-than-likely an additional fee for them.
4. I would have fond the key, but by then it wouldn't have mattered.

So, I would have been out at least $25 (probably more) and would have STILL had some stress to contend with. This on top of paying the PM company an upfront fee to place a tenant in the home (usually 60-80% on one month's rent) PLUS an additional 10-12% of rent EACH month to "manage" it. I haven't sat down and figured how much I have saved each year in PM costs for a while, but I bet it would be in the $1,000's (and maybe even >$10,000) over the last 4 years.

Monday, May 18, 2009

House #1: AC Fixed

My wife tried calling the AC repairman last Thursday to get an update. She left a message in the morning, and, not getting a call back, decided to call again in the afternoon. Still no answer. So, she called Friday morning and he answered. Turns out he scheduled a time with the tenant on Thursday evening and fixed the problem. He said the freon in the A/C was low and recharged it. (Since the AC unit is only 7-8 years old, I thought this was odd.) But, he said, there could be a slow leak (although, he didn't see one). So this MAY be a recurring problem - we'll just have to wait and see.

My wife told him to send us the bill, but to send the trip charge fee from Tuesday to the tenants, since we had it scheduled for that day and THEY didn't show (or call or email). I bet they'll be surprised when they open that piece of mail. :)

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

AC man stood-up by tenants - WTH?!?!

I am really starting to get PO'd at the tenants in House #1. About 2 weeks ago, I tried to call them regarding a pool key. I left a message on the wife's phone and the husband's phone said it was no longer in service. So, I left a message on his work phone. The next day I get an email - yes, email - from the husband saying the best way to get hold of them was via email, and to leave a message on the wife's phone as a secondary method. Huh?!?!

Anyway, as I mentioned in my previous blog entry, I sent an email to the husband on Monday saying I got his message and would call my A/C guy. I also told him someone would have to be there either on Monday or Tuesday to let the A/C guy in. The husband responded with a simple one-line message:

My wife will be home tomorrow, and thank you for the reply

So, my wife called the A/C guy and he said he wouldn't be able to get there until Tuesday late afternoon. Perfect! Since that's when the wife will be home. Instead of emailing the tenant back, we waited until Tuesday and my wife called the wife to tell her the situation. No answer - so she left a message. She said she called several more times throughout the day, and still no answer. Finally, around 5:30pm, the A/C guy called us and said he had been trying to call the wife as well, but only got her voice mail, so he left her a message. He asked us if he should still go over there or not. I told my wife "Yes - definitely" even though he would charge us a $40 trip charge if no one was home.

My wife then called the tenant's wife one last time, and still no answer. So she left yet another message saying the A/C guy was on the way and to call us back ASAP. About 15 mins later, the phone rang. Not the tenant, but the A/C guy. He said no one was answering the door, so he couldn't get inside. WTH!?!? So, he said he would leave a note on the door, saying he was there and his information. He said he would have a full day tomorrow (today), and that he wouldn't be able to get over there.

At this point both my wife and I were fuming mad. We agreed we would NOT contact the tenants AT ALL as we had done everything we could to meet their request. Either they can live with no A/C or they can call us back. Once they do call us back, we will inform them that they now us $40 for a trip charge fee. And, if we get no response in a week, I'll send them a certified letter telling them of the fact.

They've generally been good tenants - late a few times, but always paid the late fees - but this wierdness of late is getting on our nerves. I was going to send them a nice letter telling them how now is the best time to buy a house, since they were always insisting they wanted to eventually buy the house, but not now. Few things tick me off in life, but having tenants complain about a broken A/C and then not cooperating with us to get it fixed is one of them.

BTW, it is now 9:00am on Wednesday, and neither of us have received a response to my wife's messages nor have I gotten an email from them. On the way home from work today, I am going to swing by to make sure they are even still there.

Monday, May 11, 2009

Tenants

House #2

After a week of having been moved in, we finally got "the" call from the tenant of House #2. I was expecting it as the move-in never goes smooth all the time. It turns out she a list of things that she noticed were broke:

1. None of the bathroom outlets were working.
2. The garbage disposal was not working.
3. There was a leak under one of the bathroom sinks.
4. Something was wrong with the dishwasher.
5. There was an issue with the light above the kitchen sink.

The list above is almost verbatim what the tenant said on her voice mail. The one thing with tenants is that they usually think small problems are BIG problems. After my wife got done talking to the tenant, she passed the phone to me.

Problem #1 - I explained that the bathroom outlets not working was probably due to a GFCI being tripped. I told her there were 2-3 in the kitchen in one in the garage. If it was tripped, there would be a solid yellow light on one (or all) of them. She went around the kitchen and garage while I was on the phone, and said none of them were tripped. She then said she thought it was a breaker in the breaker box and had turned it off earlier, but thought she had turned it back on. Turns out it was still off. Ooops! Problem solved.

Problem #2 - It turns out the disposal WAS working, but was making a "funny" noise. I told her something probably fell in it. She said she looked inside, but didn't see anything. I told her I would come over to take a look (I had to come over for the other remaining "problems" anyway). It turns out a small nail had fallen into the disposal. She claims she didn't do it, but I know I had turned the disposal on a few weeks before to disinfect it. Problem solved.

Problem #3 - This turned out to be the only legitimate "problem" in my book. It turned out the pivot nut/connection was loose and water was dripping out from it. Problem solved.

Problem #4 - The "something wrong" was that the bottom cover appeared to be gone, exposing about 2" of crud. I told her in the 10 years we lived there, I have never taken it off, so the crud was built-up food/dirt that was now exposed from the missing cover. I asked her if it was possible one of her kids had taken it off, and she said she would ask, but had doubted it. Problem solved(?)

Problem #5 - There was nothing wrong with the light, only that the link connecting the rest of the chain to the lamp was open. My FIL helped me install the light fixtures in the house several years before and said he always did this to make it easy to adjust the chain later, if need be. I told her it shouldn't be a problem as long as no one climbs a ladder and starts messing with the light itself. Problem solved.

The whole time I was there was <20 mins. When I returned home, I explained to my wife all the "fixes". She said she hopes the tenant isn't one of those people who call every week with a list of "problems" to which I agreed. Aside from the leak under the bathroom sink, all the other things weren't really issues to me.

House #1

I checked my email on Sunday, and realized that the tenant for House #1 had sent me a message the day before at noon, saying the A/C was having the same problem as before (which was it was dripping water and not cooling). I thought it strange that (1) he sent an email and didn't call, and (2) it was over a day since he sent the email and hasn't followed up. It was dinner time, and I thought since he hadn't called or written me back than it can wait until Monday morning.

So this morning my wife called him and his wife and left messages to both. I sent a response email, also, saying I got his message and would call my A/C guy to check it out, but needed to know if someone was going to be home today or tomorrow. Still nothing for a couple of hours, until I got a response to my email. He just said "thanks. my wife will be home tomorrow." Before getting the email, my wife had called the A/C guy and explained the situation to him. He said it was not unusual for it to be clogged again as it could be a secondary problem OR the tenants aren't taking care of the place (meaning, not changing the filter). When the A/C guy goes over there to fix it, I'm going to ask him to check the filter and see if it looks like the tenants aren't taking care of the place as they are supposed to.

Friday, May 01, 2009

House #2: Tenant In

I met the tenant this morning at House #2 to give them the keys, remote openers, and paperwork. I also went around the house and pointed out things, like where the A/C filter goes (I installed a new one), how to operate the security alarm, how to maintain the salt in the W/S, and so on. The electric was turned off on Tuesday, and the tenant said they were turning it on today, although, it wasn't on when we were there. This meant I had to manually open the garage door and show how to set/unset the home security system without electric. I told the tenant once the electric is on, I would swing by and go over the security system (and anything else needing electric) again.

While talking with her, she expressed several more times that she would eventually be buying the house. I usually let this go in one ear and out the other based on past experiences with other tenants who've said the same, but never went through with it. However, I give this tenant a little more credence based on their superb credit history, etc.

I told the tenant that they would probably have a bunch of questions in the next few days, and to not hesitate to call me as I will be expecting it.