Ah, it's that time of year again. Time to update and submit my yearly "How I walked on water" report to my management to see what kind of bonus I'll receive (if any). I imagine almost all medium and large businesses have some sort of employee rating system that defines - or, at least, suggests - how well the employee did the preceding year to help the company. I had to do it in the military every year, and I have to do it each year for my current company. While syntactically different, they are semantically the same.
For my current company, we have to write a summary in the 1st quarter of each year of what all we plan to do to help the company for the rest of the year. At the end of the calendar year, we then submit a follow-up to what we planned to do and basically tell management how we should be the next CEO. I understand the purpose of such a rating system (mainly to CYA of the corporation itself), but after having lived through so many of these things, they are to me essentially a huge waste.
Case in point: this past year.
Without devulging the details of my company's rating system, I'll just say that your management - after going through all the strenious work of reading your input, their own input, etc. - give you a 1-5 number with "5" being "your fired!" and "1" being "he/she really DOES walk on water". In my almost 10 years with this company, I have never gotten a "1" (or "5" or "4"). What I find not only in my company, but in other company's is a lot has to do with corporate politics and what is referred to as the "buddy system".
A rating of "3" in our system basically means you did what was expected - nothing more, nothing less. A "2" means you went above what was expected. I got a "2" a few times early on, but have since always gotten a "3", which I thought was needed in some years, but not last year. Last year, I really busted my chops and got things done - usually far ahead of schedule. In fact, I received not one, not two, but THREE commendations (a formal award a fellow employee can give someone) for helping out people outside my area.
My reward? another "3" rating.
That really rubbed me raw, but what really angers me is that management doesn't even follow the mandated rating system the way they are supposed to. You see, you aren't rated against other people in your area, per se, but are rated against others
at the same level as yourself. I think I mentioned that I work alongside people with Ph.D.'s and such. I am just about the only person at my level working in my organization (they have formal levels here, which begin at "6" - I am a "7" and most of the people I work with are "9's" and "10's" with a couple of "8's" in the mix). So, instead of rating me against other "6's", I feel - (and maybe I'm wrong) - that I am getting rated next to those people higher up. Of course, when I mention this to management, my assertions are met with denial.
Of course, I can always hope in lieu of a good bonus, I'll get a promotion! ..... Okay, you can quit laughing now.
But then that's the life of a corporate drone. Just another reason to get out of the "rat race".